
A Police Report Doesn’t Determine Liability
You’re driving along, obeying the laws of the road, and you enter the intersection. Your light is definitely green, but the next thing you know you’re waking up in an ambulance because another vehicle had slammed into you. You’re injured, disoriented, and worried.
A few days later, you get the police report from the accident. You’re surprised to see that according to the investigating officer, you failed to yield. Then, it gets worse, because the other driver’s insurance company is already using that police report to deny your claim.
The Car Crash Captain looks at what unfolds and what your options are. The officer must make a statement based on evidence and observations. But witnesses may disagree, all evidence might not be included, and you were unconscious; you weren’t able to give a statement.
Can I Challenge an Incorrect Police Report?
What happens when the official version of events doesn’t match what actually happened?
There are two important distinctions to make here. On one hand, you have the right and responsibility to correct factual errors, but on the other hand, should you be disputing an officer’s interpretation?
Factual mistakes include:
- Wrong vehicle information
- Incorrect location
- Missing passengers
- Inaccurate identifying details.
Disputed conclusions include:
- Who had the right of way
- Who was speeding
- Was someone distracted
- Which driver caused the wreck
The law enforcement officer is not required to change their conclusion just because you disagree. But knowing where the disputes lie is the starting point to finding justice.
What Evidence Can be Used to Support Your Claim?
Fortunately, we live in a world where data is collected around the clock. Modern vehicles, modern phones, and traffic surveillance are all collecting data and evidence in the background. And that evidence can be used to support your claim of innocence.
Dashcam Footage – If you drive at all, a dashcam should be installed on your vehicle. Footage can reveal traffic violations, traffic signal status, and create a sequence of events that nobody else witnessed.
Independent Witnesses – Your passengers will likely want to corroborate your story (even if they don’t fully remember what happened). The other driver’s passenger will do the same. But a third-party independent witness doesn’t hold a stake in the outcome and can give an unbiased report.
Crash Reconstruction – Impact locations, skid marks, debris, and the damage to both vehicles all tell a story. Putting it back together can help ensure the truth comes out.
Electronic Evidence – We know the power of event data recorders, phone records, and other digital evidence that shows just what happened.
As with all wrecks, though, time isn’t on your side. While you might have up to two years to file your claim, evidence goes away. Footage is overwritten, vehicles are repaired, and witnesses can be hard to track down (and their memories fade).
The bottom line: the police report can say you’re at fault, but the evidence can challenge the insurance company’s liability decision.
Police Reports are Important, but Not the Final Verdict
Here in Texas, we have a modified comparative fault system (the legalese term is proportionate responsibility). That can be a good thing, or a bad thing.
If you’re not totally innocent (let’s suppose they ran the red light, but you were speeding), you might be determined to be 20% at fault. This means the amount you can recover is reduced by 20%. This works with any percentage of fault up to 50%; if you’re found to be 51% at fault, you can’t recover any damages.
The important part, though, is that the police at the scene doesn’t assign these percentages. This is often done through litigation where the legal process, and often a jury, determines who is at fault and by how much.
If things do go to trial, that police report might not even be admissible (it’s not automatically inadmissible, but there are circumstances where it won’t be).
Herbert Law Group Helps You Get the Final Word
The police report can influence an insurance claim, but it doesn’t decide your entire case. If you were injured in a Dallas-area wreck, and you believe that the officer got it wrong, we can help you challenge those conclusions and fight for the compensation you deserve.
We have to find out what happened first. So, give us a call at 214-414-3808 and we’ll have a free conversation to determine how we can help. No time for a call right now? Fill out the contact form and we’ll be in touch soon.